An employee and an independent contractor on your team may have similar roles and responsibilities. However, when it comes to classification, they fall under different statuses. For both payers and workers, getting this classification wrong can have real financial consequences, such as back taxes and remittances, lost deductions and labour standards violations.
This comprehensive guide explores the differences between independent contractors and employees and explains how the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) determines their classification.
The Difference Between an Employee and an Independent Contractor
An employee is a worker who performs a specific job, usually at a defined location and within the times specified by an employer. Their work is overseen by their employer, who also manages the financial aspects of the employment, including their salary, expenses, taxes and bonuses.
In contrast, an independent contractor is a self-employed worker who runs their own business and is contracted by a payer to perform specified services for a fee. They generally control how they carry out the contract and are not subject to the same level of direction or control as an employee.
CRA Employment Status Explained
Worker status refers to how a person is classified for tax and employment purposes, such as an employee or independent contractor. Here’s how to determine whether a worker is an employee or a contractor:
Determine Where the Contract Formed
Where the offeror, usually the payer, receives acceptance determines which laws apply. If the contract is formed in Quebec, a three-step approach under the Civil Code of Quebec applies. If the contract is formed in any other province or territory, common law applies. Under common law, the CRA adopts a two-step approach to determine whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor.
If common law applies, the CRA uses the following process:
1. Establish Intent
The CRA establishes what the worker and the payer intended the relationship to be. A written contract is one way to establish that intent, and it carries weight with the CRA and Tax Court judges.
Both parties to the relationship must have genuinely agreed to enter into an employer-employee or business relationship. If, however, the contract specifies the relationship as an employer-employee relationship but only one party understood or agreed to that arrangement, the CRA may look past the label.
2. Verify Intent Against Actual Working Relationship
Intent alone is not enough to establish the nature of a working relationship between two parties. For instance, if both parties signed a contract designating the worker as an independent contractor, the CRA will cross-check the stated intent against how the relationship actually operates day-to-day. If the facts of their actual relationship support an employer-employee relationship, they can outweigh the label.
Six Factors the CRA Uses to Test Your Working Relationship
Once the CRA establishes intent, it examines the following factors to determine whether the working relationship reflects that intent.

1. Control
To determine the actual working relationship, the CRA identifies who decides how, when and where the work gets done. If the employer directs the worker’s daily methods and schedule, the relationship is more likely to be an employer-employee one. Conversely, if the worker determines their own process and is accountable only for the result, that signals a business relationship.
2. Tools and Equipment
Employees typically use employer-supplied tools and equipment. In contrast, independent contractors invest in and maintain their own tools.
3. Subcontracting and Hiring Assistants
Whether or not the worker in question has the right to subcontract the work or hire assistants is another critical factor the CRA assesses. While independent contractors have such rights, employees must perform the work personally.
4. Financial Risk
Unlike employees who typically receive their agreed-upon wage regardless of business losses or project profitability, independent contractors bear certain financial risks. An independent contractor may incur fixed monthly overhead costs, such as software subscriptions and office rent. Similarly, they may be left unpaid if a client disputes the quality of their work, among other financial risks.
If every cost the worker incurs is either reimbursed or irrelevant to their take-home pay, that factor may support a finding of an employer-employee relationship.
5. Responsibility for Investment and Management
Another critical factor the CRA evaluates is whether the worker invests in their own business infrastructure and manages independently. This includes things like maintaining a bank account, carrying their own liability coverage and marketing their services to multiple clients.
The more a worker operates like an independent business, the stronger the case for a business relationship.
6. Opportunity for Profit
Independent contractors can increase their profit-earning potential by taking on more clients, negotiating better rates and working efficiently. This business-level profit opportunity is generally not available to employees who earn a fixed wage.
Consequences of Getting It Wrong
For payers, misclassification can result in owing back payments to the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Employment Insurance (EI). It can also result in a 10% penalty on unremitted amounts or 20% for repeat or gross-negligence failures in the same calendar year, plus daily-compounding interest.
The consequences of misclassification for employees may include reassessment of income, loss of deductions claimed as self-employed and loss of applicable workplace or employment standards protections.
If you’re unsure about employment status, either as a worker or a payer, you can request a CPP/EI ruling from the CRA.
What Incorporated Contractors Need to Know
Incorporated contractors, who, without their corporation, would essentially be employees of their client, face a unique risk of misclassification as a personal services business (PSB). When an incorporated contractor’s corporation is classed as a PSB, it generally cannot claim the small business deduction and may be subject to higher corporate tax rates. The CRA considers several conditions when determining PSB status, including whether the incorporated worker would be considered an employee without the corporation and whether the corporation has five or fewer full-time employees throughout the year.
In practice, this risk is especially relevant to IT contractors who operate through a corporation, work under a long-term contract, perform services on-site or as part of the client’s team, use client-supplied equipment and report to a client manager. Having more than five full-time employees throughout the year may help prevent the corporation from meeting the PSB conditions, but this is a high threshold that many one-person consulting corporations may not be equipped to meet.
As an incorporated contractor, your best bet is to get a qualified tax professional to review your working arrangement before relying on a corporation’s tax treatment.
Get Expert Guidance From CPA4IT
Given the differences in tax obligations between self-employed contractors and employees in Canada, the high stakes of misclassification are worth attention. If anything in this Canadian worker classification guide has raised questions about whether your working arrangement is defensible, the logical next step is to speak with a professional.
At CPA4IT, we specialize in providing incorporated contractors and IT professionals with PSB risk assessment, audit representation protection and incorporation services structured to help contractors stay compliant. Contact us today to request a free consultation.






